Corrections
Every correction made to this record since publication, oldest wording preserved beside the corrected wording. The register is append-only: entries are added, never edited away, and no material correction is made silently.
How to read this register
These entries come from the append-only correction ledger (data/corrections). The ledger records the superseded text, the corrected text, the date and the reason. It does not carry a separate “old status → new status” pair, so none is shown; affected pages are resolved from each entry’s record ID.
The register
21 entries. Affected pages are resolved from each entry’s record identifier back to the case files containing those records.
- TOURN-032-INC02material
- Superseded
- The public timeline placed Messi's handball late in normal/added time at the 2-2 phase, while the reconstruction treated approximately 55 minutes as settled.
- Corrected to
- Messi handled the ball and the Netherlands received a free kick. Project records currently conflict on the exact minute, so the timing is not treated as settled. His later caution arose from a separate sequence.
Reason The prepublication legal audit identified contradictory public project records. The exact minute is withdrawn as a settled fact pending primary chronology verification.
Affected pagesTournament officiating
- TOURN-009critical
- Superseded
- Red-card ban "applied to Argentina's first 2022 WCQ"
- Corrected to
- WRONG. The one-match ban time-barred (prescribed) before competitive football resumed; Messi PLAYED and SCORED (penalty, 13') v Ecuador 8 Oct 2020, Argentina 1-0. AFA/CONMEBOL (Domínguez) confirmed prescription.
Reason Goal.com Argentina (AFA/Domínguez); ESPN/EFE match report
Affected pagesTournament officiating
- Insinuations across Phase 7 entriescritical
- Superseded
- The inference that Messi's commercial arrangements were designed to "circumvent" MLS salary constraints, and the DAZN–Saudi "alignment" inference.
- Corrected to
- The inference that Messi's commercial arrangements were designed to "circumvent" MLS salary constraints is replaced with neutral language: reported outside commercial arrangements supplemented his MLS compensation. The DAZN–Saudi "alignment" inference is REMOVED (no documentary evidence links the Saudi investment to DAZN's FIFA rights payment). No implication is made that Apple, Adidas, Fanatics, Messi or Inter Miami participated in alleged AFA financial wrongdoing.
Reason Insinuations repaired; criticism, inference, allegation and established fact are kept visibly separated throughout.
- MIA-023critical
- Superseded
- Two premises in the tasking brief are themselves factually wrong: (a) that Argentina did not play Cape Verde, and (b) that Messi did not have a double assist. Messi's tournament output was previously recorded as "8 goals and 2 assists".
- Corrected to
- (a) The Cape Verde premise is inverted. Argentina DID play Cape Verde — a 3-2 win after extra time in the Round of 32 on 2026-07-03 at Miami/Hard Rock Stadium. Cape Verde SEPARATELY drew Spain 0-0 in Group H on 2026-06-15. Both facts are true and not mutually exclusive; there is no fabricated Cape Verde match to remove. (b) The double-assist premise is also wrong. Authoritative FIFA event data and every major outlet credit Messi with BOTH England goals' assists (Enzo Fernández 85'; Lautaro Martínez 90+2'). FIFA's narrative singles out the Lautaro cross, but the official record shows two assists. Messi's tournament output, re-derived match-by-match from official records, is 8 goals and 4 assists through 2026-07-17.
Reason Reconstruction, INCLUDING correction of the brief's own premises, on the documentary record. The final v Spain (2026-07-19) is left UNRESOLVED / DEVELOPING — no outcome is predicted.
Affected pagesWorld Cup 2026
- Classification language (AFA/TourProdEnter U.S. scrutiny)critical
- Superseded
- No U.S. charges filed — CONFIRMED null
- Corrected to
- No publicly accessible charge, indictment, criminal docket or DOJ announcement was located as of 2026-07-17.
Reason Absence of a located public record is NOT proof that no confidential subpoena, grand-jury activity or non-public investigative step exists.
- MIA-019critical
- Superseded
- Argentine procedural terms were used without definition and risked being equated with U.S. process.
- Corrected to
- Spanish terms are preserved and defined without equating them to U.S. process. Procesamiento = an investigating judge's reasoned interlocutory finding of sufficient suspicion to continue prosecuting — NOT a U.S.-style grand-jury indictment, NOT a trial verdict, and appealable. Its counterpoints are falta de mérito (insufficient merit to proceed) and sobreseimiento (dismissal). Embargo = precautionary asset attachment, not forfeiture. No conviction follows from an investigation, a charge, a procesamiento, or an appellate affirmance.
Reason Argentine procedural terminology. Official Argentine judicial primary sources (cij.gov.ar, fiscales.gob.ar, ARCA/AFIP) were NOT retrievable this session — flagged, with the attempted sources named.
Affected pagesAFA & TOURPRODENTER
- Phase-level conclusionmaterial
- Superseded
- decisions cut both ways with roughly equal weight
- Corrected to
- Removed; replaced with six-way classification (Section E). Missed penalties, defeats and correct offsides are NOT errors against Argentina.
Reason Methodological directive; reclassification built on FIFA/CONMEBOL match records
- TOURN-032material
- Superseded
- Messi (12') and Molina scored; Weghorst brace (83', 90+11')
- Corrected to
- Molina 35'; Messi penalty 73'; Weghorst 83' and 90+11' per official FIFA report. Base had Messi's minute wrong (12'→73').
Reason Official FIFA Full-Time Match Report (fdp.fifa.org), Version 2, 12 Dec 2022
Affected pagesTournament officiating
- TOURN-014material
- Superseded
- Stopped at 2022-05-10 appeal
- Corrected to
- Extended through 16 Aug 2022 settlement: cancellation, final fines (CHF 150,000 each, half suspended, 25% of total to WHO — per AFA's own statement), CAS withdrawal
Reason FIFA media releases; AFA statement 16 Aug 2022; football-legal.com; ESPN/AP
Affected pagesTournament officiating
- TOURN-009material
- Superseded
- CONMEBOL cited "articles 7.1 and 7.2"
- Corrected to
- The published resolution operative text cites only Art. 12.6 (fine) and Arts. 63.3/63.5 (appeal). The "7.1/7.2" attribution traces to Infobae's 2 Aug 2019 paraphrase, not the operative text. Conduct rule vs sanction-authority separated.
Reason CONMEBOL resolution (conmebol.com); Infobae 2 Aug 2019
Affected pagesTournament officiating
- TOURN-007material
- Superseded
- Zambrano "conceded a penalty was missed" implying a specific incident
- Corrected to
- Zambrano (13 Mar 2024) said "fue penal... el VAR no me llamó" but did NOT specify Alves–Agüero or Arthur–Otamendi. Ambiguity preserved and not resolved.
Reason Infobae & La Nación, 13 Mar 2024
Affected pagesTournament officiating
- TOURN-032material
- Superseded
- Lahoz was sent home and officiated no further Qatar 2022 match
- Corrected to
- Downgraded: no official FIFA source confirms disciplinary removal. He received no further tournament appointment. "Sent home" traces to Spanish radio COPE/Tiempo de Juego (relayed by CBS Sports, WION and others).
Reason Misbar fact-check; CBS Sports; football-espana; WION
Affected pagesTournament officiating
- New TOURN-038, TOURN-039material
- Superseded
- Missing penalty incidents / Copa 2021 audit
- Corrected to
- Added five Qatar 2022 penalty incident records and full Copa América 2021 final audit
Reason FIFA reports; ESPN VAR reviews; Sky; contemporaneous live logs
Documented resolution gap
TOURN-038 is a parent grouping ID, never a standalone entry: Phase 6.md Section C defines no TOURN-038 record, only the incident children TOURN-038-INC01…INC05, and TOURN-038 otherwise appears once, as a 'Related entry IDs' pointer from TOURN-032. The five penalty incidents this row says it added are therefore mapped to the four incident records actually imported. TOURN-038-INC03 is deliberately absent: it is a pure cross-reference in the addendum ('See TOURN-032-INC01') to the Netherlands penalty already recorded under TOURN-032, so importing it would have duplicated one incident under two IDs. TOURN-039 resolves directly and is listed unchanged.
Applied instead to TOURN-038-INC01, TOURN-038-INC02, TOURN-038-INC04, TOURN-038-INC05, TOURN-039
Affected pagesTournament officiating
- MIA-006material
- Superseded
- The prior "joint-second in goals / led goals+assists" phrasing and the erroneous 2024-10-19 clinch date are withdrawn.
- Corrected to
- Inter Miami clinched the 2024 Supporters' Shield on 2024-10-02 (3-2 at Columbus Crew, Lower.com Field; Messi brace 45' and 45+5'; Suárez 48'; Drake Callender saved a Cucho Hernández penalty). The 74-point MLS single-season record was set on 2024-10-19 (6-2 v New England, Chase Stadium; Messi hat-trick 78', 81', 89' plus an assist) — the SAME day FIFA publicly named Inter Miami its CWC host (MIA-009). Messi's official 2024 line is corrected to 20 goals, 16 assists = 36 goal contributions in 19 matches (1,485 minutes).
Reason On methodology: MLS's published figure (16 assists) matches ESPN/Opta's independent figure, indicating the 16 are primary assists; MLS's historical secondary-assist practice could not be fully verified this session and is flagged.
Affected pagesInter Miami & MLS
- MIA-014material
- Superseded
- "Likely repeat MVP"
- Corrected to
- The official 2025-12-09 determination: Messi won the 2025 Landon Donovan MLS MVP with 70.43% of the aggregate vote (83.05% media, 55.17% players, 73.08% clubs; runner-up Anders Dreyer of San Diego FC took 11.15%), becoming the first player to win it in consecutive seasons and second two-time winner (Preki, 1997/2003). Verified 2025 totals: 29 goals, 19 assists = 48 goal contributions in 28 matches (2nd-most in a season, one behind Vela's 49); MLS Golden Boot (29); playoffs 6 goals, 9 assists = 15 (single-postseason record); MLS Cup MVP. Inter Miami won MLS Cup 3-1 over Vancouver on 2025-12-06.
Reason Official MVP determination replaces a placeholder.
Affected pagesInter Miami & MLS
- MIA-010material
- Superseded
- The prior recorded agent was Sousa & Assoc (Orlando), and the record used an incorrect "Tour Print, LLC" search URL.
- Corrected to
- Registered agent corrected to JOSEFINA A GATTEI PA (800 SE 4th Ave, Suite 704, Hallandale Beach FL 33009; name/address changed 2023-05-10). The incorrect "Tour Print, LLC" search URL is withdrawn. Registered agent, authorized manager (Erica Gabriella Gillette, carried from the prior entry) and any reported beneficial owner are DISTINCT roles — a registered agent is only a statutory service-of-process designee and implies nothing about ownership or control.
Reason Corporate file correction. The official sunbiz.org entity-detail page and annual-report PDFs could not be fully retrieved this session (INACCESSIBLE); only a search-results snippet and third-party aggregators were obtained — flagged.
Affected pagesAFA & TOURPRODENTER
- MIA-008material
- Superseded
- The regulations were cited via a mirror URL, and the exact verbatim text of Articles 11.1 and 11.4 (the "Host (club TBC) | 1 | …" row) could NOT be verified this session.
- Corrected to
- The official FCWC25 Regulations PDF exists on digitalhub.fifa.com, titled "Regulations for the FIFA Club World Cup 2025™ OCTOBER 2024," but it BLOCKS automated retrieval (ROBOTS_DISALLOWED). Substance is confirmed by FIFA's official media release: "The final slot is allocated to a club from the host country, with further details being provided in due course." The distinction is preserved between: (a) the regulation's approval/effective date (document dated October 2024); (b) its public-availability date; (c) the Shield clinch (2024-10-02); and (d) FIFA's public selection of Inter Miami (2024-10-19). The regulation establishes only what the rule did and did not specify — it does NOT prove FIFA's private motive. The "2024-10-03" FIFA Council date could not be independently confirmed.
Reason Regulations citation corrected to the official FIFA document. NOTE (Phase 8, Annex B C-04/C-05): this correction is itself SUPERSEDED — the official PDF was subsequently retrieved and quoted, Article 49 confirms FIFA Council approval on 3 October 2024 with immediate effect, and Article 11.4 reads "Host (club TBC) | 1 | One club (access for the club occupying this slot will be determined by FIFA at a later stage)."
Affected pagesClub World Cup host berth
- MIA-005material
- Superseded
- "Inaugural Leagues Cup 2023"
- Corrected to
- "Inaugural Leagues Cup 2023" is an ERROR. A 2019 edition (champion Cruz Azul) and a 2021 edition (champion León) preceded it; 2020 was cancelled; 2022 was a non-competitive Showcase. Per the leagues' own descriptions, the 2023 edition was the first expanded all-club edition — "all MLS and Liga MX teams — 47 teams in total with 77 matches hosted in Canada and the United States," with the top three qualifying for the 2024 Concacaf Champions Cup. Correct formulation: Inter Miami won the first expanded all-club edition under the redesigned format, not the inaugural Leagues Cup.
Reason Leagues Cup terminology correction.
Documented resolution gap
MIA-005 is the superseded base entry and is not in the corpus: Phase 7.md — byte-identical (MD5 6b0fff987cbff20e2527a9b3e2ba0082) to the file supplied as Phase_7_BASE_MIA.md, per the 18 July 2026 checksum audit — is the correction addendum, and its Section 2 contains no MIA-005 entry. Its corrected successor is MIA-025, which the addendum states in its own words: MIA-025's Relevance field reads 'Corrects the "inaugural" error (C6) and completes the 2023 chronology', C6 being this ledger row. MIA-025's neutral headline and confirmed-facts already carry the corrected formulation ('the first expanded all-club edition', 'NOT the inaugural Leagues Cup'), and the imported event carries secondaryStatuses ['corrected']. The mapping is the addendum's own attribution, not an inference. Without it this material correction would remain invisible on the record it corrects, which CLAUDE.md rule 12 forbids.
Applied instead to MIA-025
Affected pagesInter Miami & MLS
- TOURN-035, TOURN-036, othersminor
- Superseded
- Absolute nulls ("NONE located", "no sanction exists")
- Corrected to
- Replaced with "no publicly available record was located this session."
Reason Directive
Documented resolution gap
No live target in the dataset. TOURN-035 and TOURN-036 appear nowhere in the corpus except Phase 6.md's own correction addendum, where each is a bare 'AMENDED — null-language correction only' stub carrying a unique ID, the amendment sentence and a last-verified date — no event date, headline, summary, classification or source. The Phase 6 base TOURN dossier that would supply that text is not in the corpus: the file supplied as Phase_6_BASE_TOURN.md is byte-identical (MD5 905f9f451a9226137fc3116055398e62) to the addendum itself, per the 18 July 2026 checksum audit. Neither entry was therefore importable as a timeline event, and inventing a date or headline to give this row a target is prohibited (CLAUDE.md). The row's own third token, 'others', is additionally non-exhaustive by construction. The amendment it records — replacing absolute nulls such as 'NONE located' with 'no publicly available record was located this session' — is nonetheless already honoured throughout the imported corpus as a house wording rule. See content/record/document-audit.mdx §2.5.
Applied tono published record. The correction is preserved here because the ledger is append-only, and this page is the only place it appears.
- Finalissimaminor
- Superseded
- Not addressed
- Corrected to
- SCOPE RULING: 2022 Finalissima (Argentina 3-0 Italy, Wembley) is a joint CONMEBOL–UEFA competition, outside Phase 6's named scope; recorded as a one-line scope note (uncontroversial 3-0).
Reason UEFA.com; ESPN; Wikipedia→primary
- Source ledger (Phase 7 Section 6)minor
- Superseded
- Primary-source ledger
- Corrected to
- "Primary-source ledger" is renamed "Source ledger" and each source is typed by its actual nature (Section 6). No news report is classified as a primary official record merely for reporting an event.
Reason Ledger rename and per-source typing.
Where else corrections appear
This register is not the only place a correction is visible, and it is not intended to be read alone.
- Each corrected record carries its own correction banner and revision history, in place, on the record — on the timeline entry, on the case file and on the claim page. Where a ledger entry corrects a phase-level conclusion rather than a single record, there is no one record to carry it, and the entry is marked above as a documented resolution gap and appears only here.
- Where records conflict rather than one superseding another, the conflict is rendered as a conflict — three incompatible accounts of the same fixture are shown as three accounts, not merged into one.
- What the research did not establish at all is a different matter from what it got wrong and fixed. That is on research status.